Cooking food really matters; from selecting the product to putting it under treatment by the best culinary expert that you can manage and ending it up on the dinner table. How well the food is cooked also matters on what you cook it in, so cooking equipment should be chosen wisely. Based on the material of manufacturing, brand, durability, use, and other considerations are the top ten choices of the best roasting pans out there.

Roasting pans can both be a source of convenience when having guests over as well but can also add to your worries when it comes to cleaning them. So to make selecting the best roasting pan easier for you, here are the pans you can find online as well what aspects to consider when buying one.

1.    The Viking Large Roasting Pan

best roasting pan

With a thick consistency and a tri-ply manufacturing, the Viking Large Roasting Pan serves for a good cooking escapade for many culinary enthusiasts. The tri-ply makes for it to be composed of three layers of manufacturing material- i.e. it is made up of aluminum encased between two layers stainless steel giving it a polished mirror shine.

Its use is not limited just to oven cooking, if you let it work its magic on to the stove, you will surely not regret it.  The Viking Large Roasting Pan will make your gravy and broth, which was once of a dripping loose consistency, to the ultimate dense and flavorful perfection ready to tantalize your taste buds. It comes with a rather heavy price tag.


2.    Granite Ware Oval Roaster

best turkey roasting pan

If it’s majorly holiday cooking you wish to use the roasting pan for, the Granite Ware Oval Roaster is the one to be considered. For a slow-cooked holiday meal for Thanksgiving, the Granite Ware Oval Roaster will cook every meal you cook inside it to ultimate perfection with its strong carbon steel body. The carbon steel body will absorb the right amount of heat and contain it in the pot to cook the contents with ample warmth.

The Granite Ware Oval Roaster is one of a kind; firstly because of the material it’s manufactured from and secondly because of the dark color it has. These factors enable it to absorb the maximum amount of heat that is released within the oven and therefore reduce the cooking time of the meal.


3.    Cuisinart Ovenware Classic Collection Roasting Pan

best roasting pan for turkey

Made of a heavy steel material, the Cuisinart Ovenware Classic Collection roasting pan claims to ensure a uniform heating when cooking all types of meals. It comes with a moveable rack which, after cooking, allows you to rift off any protein that you’ve cooked and easily drain its fats and oils that remain in the pan.

Moreover, Cuisinart Ovenware Classic Collection is manufactured on the basis of a universal roasting pan size which would not hinder when you want to cook inside your oven. Hence, you will not have to worry about measurements of your oven if you’re considering buying the Cuisinart Ovenware Classic Collection roasting pan.


4.    Granite Covered Rectangular Roaster

roasting pan

Also manufactured using a strong carbon steel material, the Granite Covered Rectangular Roaster is also characterized by a dark surface which absorbs and contains in it the maximum heat possible –ultimately leading to a cooked to perfection meal. Though the rectangular shape makes it hard to clean corners.



5.    Norpro Stainless Steel Broil

best roasting pan 2016

The Norpro Stainless Steel Broil is the roasting pan that is characterized by a very unique and differentiating style as compared to the rest of the roasting pans in this list. With its unique design, it comes with a perforated top that will allow you to conveniently rid the meal off of grease and fats.

It is characterized by a rather complicated and bumpy design that cleaning it would require more effort than with all the other pans in the list. Moreover, it’s composed of a stainless steel material, which gives you a roasting pan that is both strong and durable.


6.    All-Clad E87599 Hard Anodized Aluminum Nonstick Roasting Pan

best roasting pan

The best roasting pan isn’t only the one that gives your raw produce the right treatment of heat and cooking convenience for it to end up on the dining table. In fact, it is important for the roasting pan to be less hassle during use and after you’ve finished eating your meal when you come to wash it up. Often material of the roasting pan proves for the contents to stick such that removing them takes a huge amount of effort from you.

The All-Clad E87599 Hard Anodized Aluminum Nonstick Roasting Pan will be an angel for you both during and after cooking. Characterized by a nonstick coating, it will allow you to clean up much faster and with lesser strain. It is tall in its existence that saves off harmful spilling of contents when removing the roasting pan from the oven and the large handles it comes with, only add to your better and convenient assistance.

The All-Clad E87599 Hard Anodized Aluminum Nonstick Roasting Pan also comes with a V-shaped nonstick rack that allows the juices and fats to collect down in the pan that can be used for basting or turned into a gravy to go with your meal.

Either you clean it by hand or pop it in the dishwasher, both will be a breeze for you.


7.    Calphalon Unison Contemporary Nonstick Roaster

best turkey roasting pan

This roasting pan also comes with a non-stick as well as a great uniform cooking treatment to the contents you cook inside it. The Calphalon Unison Contemporary Nonstick Roaster is made up of a heavy aluminum gauge material that allows your contents to gain that extra brown that you wish in your meal.

This roasting pan claims to hold safely and cook perfectly a turkey of up to a weight of 25 pounds. Because it is nonstick, it will cook your meal in less fat which as compared to roasting pans that are not nonstick. In turn, resulting in a healthier meal for your family’s consumption. To top all of its amazing qualities, the Calphalon Unison Contemporary Nonstick Roaster comes with a warranty for a lifetime, if this isn’t proof enough of its durability and everything it claims, then what is?


8.    Cook Pro 561 4-Piece All-in-1 Lasagna and Roasting Pan

best roasting pan 2018

If it’s roast meat you wish to cook, then the Cook Pro 561 4-Piece All-in-1 Lasagna and Roasting Pan is a must-have in your culinary space. The Cook Pro 561 4-Piece All-in-1 Lasagna and Roasting Pan comes manufactured with a stainless steel material as well as two pans and roasting racks that differ in size. These racks can allow you to cook with their different sizes as per your preferred convenience.

With its stainless steel handles, taking it out and putting it in the oven is an easily conducted process. If you’re wondering, the Cook Pro 561 4-Piece All-in-1 Lasagna and Roasting Pan work best for cooking a roast, lasagna, and other layered meals as it has got high sides.


9.    Progressive International Stainless Steel Roasting Pan

best roasting pan

Progressive international claims to be the best for their kitchenware. Their roasting pan is a product that speaks for itself. The Progressive International Stainless Steel Roasting Pan comes with a stainless steel pan, a roasting rack, folding handles that are easy to grip as well as a spatula for serving. The company claims to manufacture appliances that promote inventive and fun cooking escapades using their products, including the roasting pan.


10.    Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Roast Pan

best roasting pan

The Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Roast Pan is all about design, durability, and quality. Specifically, the Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Roast Pan works best for baking purposes and does not fall short in fulfilling what it claims. It is modified as a rectangular roasting pan that comes with easy and convenient lifting with its release handle. Furthermore, the Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Roast Pan happens to be nonstick and offers you an easy to clean experience after cooking. With this pan in your culinary space, your inner baker would just pop out with creative ways to cook with the Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Roast Pan.


Why Roasting Pans

  • The best assistance a roasting pan can be to you is if you’re hosting lunch or dinner to a large number of people. This is the main reason why roasting pans are largely preferred as they provide for maximum cooking space for most servings.
  • If it’s a lamb roast you’re cooking, a green bean casserole or lasagna, the roasting pan will provide with the maximum space and allow for the food to be cooked perfectly.
  • Roasting Pans allow for a uniform cooking process, through which even the toughest and thickest of pieces of meat are cooked to succulent, juicy, and tender perfection.

How to Select the Right Roasting Pan

The only right way to select the best roasting pan for your culinary escapades at home can be done through several considerations

1.    Based on Use

When you’re selecting a roasting pan, it’s important for you to have a clear picture of how and for what cooking purpose do you wish to use the roasting pan. Whether you wish to use it for baking purposes, for which it needs to be oven safe etc.

2.    Based on Material

If your roasting pan usage is limited to only festivals and holiday cooking such as Christmas dinner or Thanksgiving, then you need a pan that doesn’t rust that easily so that when you take it out every year. A roasting pan is rust free because of the durable material it’s composed of. Example of suggested roasting pan material is copper, it is a good conductor of heat and cools down easily too.

3.    Based on Size of the Roasting Pan

Size of the pan should be made a priority among other factors in the list of checking whether the particular pan is suitable to take home. Be sure to measure it in height and width as this would serve as a precaution in case you take home a pan without measuring, only to find out it does even fit in your oven.

Moreover, if it’s too big for whatever you plan to cook in it, most of it will most definitely remain empty, which allows the contents to burn giving way to half overcooked meal or undercooked. To avoid a trip as an added hassle in going back to return it, it is far better if you leave home after you’ve measured your oven and then select a pan according to it. If you have a lot of choices finalized, these little considerations will add up to shorten your list of potential roasting pan candidates until you’re left with the one.

4.    Handles

If you’re confused about choosing a roasting pan, compare their handles because it will help. You should preferably ditch the pan that comes with no handles at all on the basis of how hard and unsafe it would be to remove the pan from the oven and back again.

Furthermore, if the roasting pan comes with handles check and scrutinize how strong they are. Flimsy handles are as equal to a pan without handles. Ensure that the handles are sturdy strong and easy to grip on so that they do not hinder with your cooking.

5.    Racks

Similar to handles, not all roasting pans come equipped with roasting racks. Racks can be very beneficial when cooking poultry as the fats, oils, and juice are easily separated from the protein and the decision is left on you to whether use them or discard them.

Furthermore, since the rack lifts up the protein or vegetable placed on it, it ensures better browning by being closer to the heat energy above. Roasting pans with racks allow you to arrange the contents as you please, by changing the positioning of the rack which serves for a convincing meal.

6.    Non-Stick 

Having a nonstick pan is not a compulsion as pans that are not nonstick also allow for comfortable cooking with a convincing result. However, if you happen to choose a nonstick pan here’s how it will benefit you- for one, it will have you apply less effort into cleaning it as contents come off easier when scrubbing a nonstick pan.  Furthermore, you will end up using less oil or fat to cook in because there are fewer chances for the contents to stick at the bottom, ending up with a healthier meal.

However, non-stick pans do fall short in the browning criteria as they do not allow for the meat to be fully cooked because of its nonstick nature. If you love browning more than convenience and would prefer a pan that is not nonstick all you need to do is soak it instantly into hot water so contents become easier to remove when it comes to doing the dishes.

7.    Lid or Not 

Roasting pots with lids can prove to be a great companion when cooking a stew or broth. The lid would allow even cooking with all the flavors remaining in contact with the protein you’re cooking. What most people believe to be true is that roasting pans with lids cook the food well but the contents or protein you have cooked does not get the ‘crisp’ factor.

What you can do in this case is after cooking your meal onto the stove, drain the contents and put the roasting dish into a preheated oven.

A roasting pan without a lid is as useful, but cooking in it would involve checking up on the contents and turning sides to ensure even cooking.

8.    Shape- Oval, Rectangular or Both 

Most roasting pans come with two major modifications i.e. either they are oval or rectangular. The shape you prefer should be based on what you wish to cook in it. If its turkey, chicken or beef pot pie then oval shape would work better because it is easier to set up a pie crust or whisk contents on it. Whereas, the oval-shaped roasting pans have a limited surface area than rectangular ones.

Rectangular shaped roasting pans provide more surface area for cooking which allows cooking for more people as compared to with an oval-shaped roasting pan. However, the rectangular roasting pan comes with tight corners that prove awkward when trying to put food evenly in the pan.

If you prefer a mix of both, you can get a rectangular pan with rounded corners for your better suiting.

9.    The weight of the Roasting Pan

The weight of the roasting pan will be judged by how much heat the pan will absorb. If it’s very heavy, it will take more time to cook its contents. Carrying could also be a dangerous task with heavy roasting pans, as they will be difficult to move from counter to oven and back again.

Instead, if the pan is too thin, it will most likely burn the contents from the base and chances are food will be undercooked. Light pans are more likely to carry less weight hence the pan you’re selecting should be at an intermediate stance i.e. not too heavy, nor too light.

10.    Affordability

With all of the above comparisons do not forget to consider and compare the prices of the candidates you have selected. On that note, do not go for a pan that you think is a good deal because it’s cheaper than others. There’s a reason why it’s more affordable -among important reasons is the fact that it is most likely manufactured from a cheap material fit for a short time of use.

Whereas, expensive brands offer you excellence and durability with a slightly high, but justified price, for all the right reasons in a roasting pan.

11.    Brand Prominence 

If it’s a known brand, it is most likely proven for it to be reputable in its products to keep a steady and good image in the market. Good brands earn their name by introducing products that speak for themselves upon use and do not rely too much on marketing. Whereas, less famous brands survive over cheap marketing, so remain on the lookout for products that don’t offer what they claim but are too good to be true.

12.    Reviews

A product can be critically analyzed based on its reviews and ratings by people in blogs as well as online stores. If you wish to buy any of the pans above do go through online reviews on sites you deem have authentic reviewing of products. Moreover, you can look up all the above-mentioned roasting pans on this list over at Amazon.

The best roasting pan can be decided upon considering the above factors and conduct thorough comparisons. There is not a pan that’s perfect in all its existence, just a bunch of pans that people prefer more than others because of their convenience and affordability.

Roasting pans do have the festive characteristic affiliated for a Christmas meal- but whether you use it over special occasions or all year round, one thing is for sure- roasting pans do give a meal its hearty aura!

What to Cook in a Roasting Pan

Roasting pans are one of those cookware products that highlight an important meal based on sacred occasions of thanksgiving and Christmas etc. So considering you’re cooking for a big family gathering; hence, you would want to cook something that’s uniform and would prove sufficient for all.

Dishes that could be perfect to cook in a roasting pan are lasagna, green bean casserole, baked vegetables, roast potatoes, chicken or beef pot pie etc.

Although it is not necessary to limit using your roast pan to certain occasions, day to day meals can be cooked in it as well, like for e.g. making beef stew. All you have to do is add all the ingredients and tuck the roasting tray into the oven after which you can continue with your daily chores and check up on it once it is cooked.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here